AS REGULAR visitors to pubs and clubs know only too well, implementing the ban on real cigarettes has been patchy at best, yet - much to the chagrin of the makers of electronic cigarettes - the police and health officials are seeking to expand that ban to include electronic smoking cessation aids.
Of all EU countries, only Belgium, Malta and Slovakia have so far extended their smoking ban to include electronic cigarettes in enclosed public places, bars, restaurants and the workplace, even though they contain no tobacco.
Police chief Michalis Papageorgiou said Cyprus needs to join these countries and adopt strict regulations on the use of electronic cigarettes in public spaces irrespective of future EU directives on the issue.
“Regardless of whether the European Union will issue a legally binding directive regarding electronic cigarettes, we will act to best serve the people of Cyprus,” he said.
“And we believe that banning the use of electronic cigarettes from public places will benefit the public.”
Draft legislation banning electronic cigarette use in public places was proposed in January but has yet to be sent to parliament for approval.
Acting director of the health services, Christos Christou said this week his department will consult importers and producers of electronic cigarettes during the process of putting the law together.
With no legislation yet passed, electronic cigarettes can be bought in kiosks, pharmacies and supermarkets and smoked anywhere.
“We will follow EU proposals until a regulatory body is put in place,” Christou said.
The ministry is still awaiting results of an investigative committee to see exactly how harmful electronic cigarettes might be, but it has decided to take the advice of the World Health Organisation in considering electronic cigarettes as a health hazard.
According to the European Commission’s proposal for a revised Tobacco Product Directive, electronic cigarettes would fall under the legal framework for medicinal products if they contain levels of nicotine above certain thresholds. The nicotine threshold would be identified by considering the nicotine content of nicotine replacement therapies (NRTs) that have already received a marketing authorisation by member states.
Manufacturers have ensured some electronic cigarettes are easily distinguished from normal ones in various ways. Some have tips that glow green when they are inhaled; others are small metal cylinders that look nothing like cigarettes. Most, however, are made to look as close to the real thing as possible, and, according to Christou, that is another reason why the ban should be extended.
“Many electronic cigarettes look just like tobacco cigarettes and they emit smoke(sic), so you can imagine the confusion and difficulty some restaurant and cafι owners would have upholding the law,” he said.
This opinion is shared by the police chief who also believes that clamping down on electronic cigarette use in public areas will aid in upholding the current tobacco cigarette ban.
“It’s just not practical to expect a bar owner to go round his establishment taking a close look at whether someone is smoking a real cigarette or not,” Papageorgiou said.
Electronic cigarettes claim to aid people who want to quit smoking, much like NRTs but Christou said none of the electronic cigarette companies have received authorisation from pharmaceutical services.
“If they are to be approved and put on the market as a pharmaceutical product then the whole procedure would change,” Christou said. “Our goal is to protect public health, we are not interested in taxation or pharmaceutical and tobacco companies’ agendas.”
Another issue is that while tobacco cigarettes should only be sold to adults, anyone can go into a kiosk and buy an electronic cigarette.
Normal tobacco cigarettes contain more than 4,000 chemicals and 60 known carcinogens.
According to information given to the Sunday Mail by E-lites, a British manufacturer of electronic cigarettes, research carried out by Boston and Alberta universities have found that electronic cigarettes are at least 99 per cent safer than normal tobacco cigarettes.
“Electronic cigarettes are free of tar, tobacco, carbon monoxide and many other carcinogens and hidden chemicals, and therefore allow smokers to satisfy their nicotine cravings, in a familiar hand-to-mouth format, without damaging their health,” co-founder and director of E-Lites, Adrian Everett told the Sunday Mail.
“The safety record of electronic cigarettes is highly impressive with millions of products being sold globally, yet no record of any harm being caused by their use. The same cannot in fact be said for medically licensed NRT products,” he added.
According to E-Lites the success rate of electronic cigarettes is much higher than NRT products which have a 98 per cent fail rate after 12 months.
With many kiosks and pharmacies currently selling various electronic cigarettes, it is down to the consumer to make an educated decision on which product to purchase. This is why E-Lites are currently only available from pharmacies.
“We began selling E-Lites at kiosks and pharmacies but didn’t make many sales at kiosks where they would sell cheaper Chinese products,” Everett revealed. “We then decided to only sell them at pharmacies as they are generally more trusted by the public.”
He said that while many electronic cigarettes currently on the market are not regulated, this was not strictly true of his product.
“Our products are not regulated as medicinal products but that is not to say that they are not regulated at all. We are in fact regulated under many statutes of UK law and all our products are independently tested in UK laboratories. E-Lites were in fact the first Company to obtain ECITA’s (Electronic Cigarette Industry Trade Association) Industry Standard of Excellence, a mark which surpasses the requirements of UK statute,” he added.
Nobacco is another company which sells electronic cigarettes in Cyprus.
“Electronic cigarettes emit steam when someone smokes one,” a Nobacco sales representative said. “If they were to ban electronic cigarettes from enclosed spaces then they would have to ban people from cooking indoors because that emits steam too.”
The health services, however, refute claims that the steam emitted from the electronic cigarettes is harmless.
“The steam created by the devices is caused by combustion, by using the nicotine cartridges so any steam that is emitted will contain harmful odours,” Christou insisted.
The response to a possible ban on electronic cigarettes from bar and cafι owners has been mixed.
“I have already lost business because of the smoking ban as unlike others I don’t let people smoke inside,” said owner of Nicosia’s Brickyard Bar & Grill, Stavros Prokommenos. “I don’t think I would enforce an electronic cigarette ban indoors because the smoke that comes out isn’t harmful.”
Owner of El Classico Cafι in Engomi, Stavros Andreou stated that he would uphold the law if it was put in place although his cafι was made with smokers in mind.
“I have a total of 240 seats at my cafι with 180 outside so making people sit outside if they want to smoke electronic cigarettes shouldn’t affect my business at all,” he said.
Most electronic cigarettes resemble the real thing as far as possible